The England head coach despised the term Bazball from its inception, considering it overly simplistic and maybe foreseeing how it could be weaponised down the line. Currently, down 2-0 in an Test series in Australia that started with great expectations, it has become the butt of mockery from Australia.
However McCullum has not helped himself either. After the crushing loss at the Gabba, his insistence that, if there was an issue, England were 'too prepared' prior to the pink-ball match was like trying to put out a bin fire with petrol. It risks becoming his epitaph as national coach if performances do not take an upturn.
On one level, you almost have to admire his dedication to the philosophy. As much as he claims to ignore outside criticism, he must have been all too aware of an England team often described as freewheeling and lacking preparation.
The truth, as ever, is not so simple. England enjoy golf just as much during their necessary down time as their opponents and they train just as much. Prior to the Gabba Test, they did more, completing five days compared to Australia's three, due to their limited experience to the pink Kookaburra ball and the changes in seeing conditions.
The Debate of Readiness and Practice
The coach's point about being "excessively ready" was that those additional training days were his decision – the instance he wavered in his belief that minimal preparation is best. It meant a significant amount of mental energy was used up before they even took the field in the intensity of Australia's fortress. And though net practice are a chance to refine skills, they can also become a comfort zone; zero consequence work that mainly keeps the reactions quick.
Fixtures are congested such that pre-series state games were unavailable (and uncertain value, when you consider England having played three before the 5-0 series loss in 2013-14). What is harder to square is the dismissal of domestic red-ball cricket as a worthwhile exercise more broadly, as shown by Jacob Bethell's wasted summer.
On-Field Shortcomings and Philosophical Stagnation
Only playing hardens cricketers for the various scenarios they encounter, and it is in this area where England have so far been found lacking. The issue is not just with the batting – as poor as some of the shot selection has been – but an attack that seems leaderless. No bowler has demonstrated the patience or control that the exceptional Australian paceman and his teammates have displayed.
McCullum's unconventional approach was freeing during its initial year, an effective, apt solution to shake off the torpor that preceded it. The frustration now stems from how it has apparently not evolved past that initial phase – the lack of an upgrade to the original software that has seen results decline to 14 wins and 14 losses from their last 30 Tests.
Player Spotlight and Selection Dilemmas
Among them is Jamie Smith, a gifted player, no question, but one who is being mercilessly targeted on both edges and has dropped two crucial opportunities as wicketkeeper. The situation is not aided when your counterpart, the Australian keeper, has just produced a virtuoso display.
Going by McCullum's words in the aftermath, England appear set to persist with Smith in Adelaide. The hope – similar to the broader situation – is that a return to a traditional match environment unleashes his top form, with Perth's trampoline surface and the unfamiliar day-night format now in the past.
Another option is to enact the plan stumbled across during the victorious series in New Zealand last year by moving the batsman down to his more natural home as a busy No. 5 or 6, handing him the gloves, and selecting a new No 3. Bethell scored runs for the Lions recently, or perhaps Will Jacks could perform a similar role to Moeen Ali in 2023.
Ultimately, none of this is ideal, with Australia's better fundamentals having destroyed pre-series optimism and forced the broader philosophy into the harsh glare of scrutiny.